Heavy Workload is the Top Stressor in P&C Insurance. How Much of It Is Avoidable?

Posted in: Blog

Heavy workload is still the biggest source of stress in the Canadian P&C insurance industry. In Canadian Underwriter’s 2026 Mental Health Survey, 63% of the 530 industry professionals who responded named it as a top stressor. That’s unchanged from last year and the survey points to the ongoing labour shortage as a main driver.  

There’s no quick fix for a talent shortage. But a large share of what fills an underwriter’s or customer service representative’s or broker’s day isn’t direct insurance work at all. It’s typing the same information into a second system, assembling documents by hand, exporting Excel sheets and manually cleaning and combining them before emailing them elsewhere.  

That part of the workload is avoidable. This article looks at where administrative time goes, which tasks can be automated today, and what happened at three Canadian insurance organizations when they took that work off their teams’ plates.  

What’s driving workload in P&C insurance? 

The short answer is fewer people carrying the same volume of work. Canadian Underwriter’s survey identifies the labour shortage as the main driver behind workplace stress.  

Other sources of heavy workload include: 

  • Setting unrealistic deadlines 
  • Uneven distribution of workload 
  • Lack of defined business priorities 
  • Excessive manual processes and duplicate entry  
  • Outdated legacy systems 
  • Compliance or regulatory changes 
  • Natural disasters or catastrophic events causing claim surges 
  • Fears over job security 
  • Organizational changes 

While Canadian Underwriter reported that the overall picture improved slightly from last year’s peak, the share of respondents describing themselves as “highly stressed” rose from 34% to 41%.  

These numbers are real people. Technology isn’t the answer to solving all of these causes of a heavy workload. Reasonable targets, good management, and open conversations about wellbeing matter. What technology can do is remove work that never needed a person in the first place. That’s what the rest of this article is about. 

Where does the time actually go? 

A lot of time is spent doing the administrative work that surrounds every quote, policy change, renewal, and claim. Ask an underwriter or broker or claims specialist to walk you through a typical day and you’ll hear some version of this: 

  • Rekeying submissions (such as from an emailed application) 
  • Screen-switching between systems 
  • Building documents manually  
  • Duplicate entry into multiple systems (such as typing premium and fees into an accounting or payment system) 
  • Rebuilding renewals 
  • Producing bordereaux 
  • One-off compliance checks 

None of these tasks is hard, but they’re repetitive, time-consuming and pile up quickly. Time spent doing this administrative work pulls the employee away from customer interactions or work that needs an insurance professional’s judgement. 

Which insurance administrative tasks can be automated? 

Most of the list above can be automated with a modern policy administration system, using a mix of rules-based automation, integration and AI. Here are a few examples: 

Task  How it’s done manually  How it works when automated 
Submission intake  Read the application, prior decs and loss runs, then type it in  AI reads the attachments and fills in the questions, risks and coverages. Anything it can’t read is flagged for a person instead of guessed 
Inbox triage  Search for the customer or open quote before starting  The submission is matched to an existing customer or quote, or a new customer is set up 
Vehicle details  Look up and type in year, make and model  Enter the VIN and the details fill in automatically 
Referral decisions  Review every quote against the guidelines  Rules decide whether each quote proceeds, is referred or is declined. People see only the exceptions 
Sanctions checks  Search each name individually  Checks run inside the workflow through an integration 
Dec pages and documents  Assemble and name each file by hand  Generated automatically on issue or change, with branding and broker details. Regenerated after corrections 
Accounting entries  Re-enter premiums and fees in the GL  Every transaction posts a journal entry to the accounting system automatically 
Payment schedules  Calculate instalments by hand, then again after changes  Instalment plans are calculated automatically and recalculated after mid-term changes 
Renewals  Work the diary, rebuild the term, re-rate and re-issue  The next term is created, rated and issued automatically. Only specific exceptions go to a person 
Bordereaux  Export to Excel, format, attach and email each month  The layout is defined once, then the report is built and emailed to the carrier on schedule 
Broker book transfers  Move policies one at a time  Upload a spreadsheet and the transfer runs as a batch 

Every item on this list works off the same policy record, which is what removes the duplicate data entry. Information is entered once and flows to documents, accounting and reporting from there. For more on how integrations make that possible, see our guide to API connectivity in policy administration systems. 

Automation That Removes Work vs Automation That Moves It 

Not all automation reduces workload. Some of it just moves the work. A tool that generates a document but needs someone to check every line hasn’t saved much time. An AI tool that guesses at missing information creates a new job of finding and fixing its mistakes.  

Automation that actually lowers the workload does so by handling the routine on its own and sending people only the exceptions, with an explanation attached. In practice this looks like: 

  • Renewals go through untouched, unless there’s a flag that stops them. For example, a premium financing agreement needs to be re-signed, additional information is required, or there’s a current binding suspension. 
  • Referrals follow your rules, so quotes that fit your appetite will proceed and underwriters are flagged to review ones that need their judgement. 
  • AI flags what it can’t read instead of guessing.  

This matters for both efficiency and trust.  

What happens when the workload drops?  

When avoidable work goes away, teams catch up, then move to work that needs them. Here’s what that looked like for three Canadian insurance organizations.  

My Mutual Insurance: Caught Up for the First Time in Over 10 Years 

My Mutual is a Saskatchewan P&C mutual with more than 20,000 active policies. On its legacy system, new business, renewals, endorsements and cancellations were backlogged by three to eight months. Staffing needs kept rising, and so did errors. 

After moving to an automated platform, My Mutual cleared that backlog for the first time in more than a decade. Underwriting efficiency and policy issuance improved by 35%, and auto-generated renewals rose by 20%. Most importantly, staff moved out of administrative tasks and into service and sales roles. 

You can read the full mutual insurer case study here. 

Harvard Western Insurance: One Person, 2200 Policies in 30 Days 

Harvard Western, Saskatchewan’s largest locally owned brokerage, runs high-volume programs with thousands of small policies. Documents are generated and delivered automatically the moment a policy is issued. Bordereaux, renewals, payments and sanctions checks are automated as well. 

I can now issue 2,200 individual policies, complete with declaration pages, wordings, and certificates of insurance, within 30 days with one staffing complement. — Mike Hordichuk, VP, Product Development, Harvard Western Insurance 

Today, two people manage 5,700 policies and $1.5 million in premium across three programs, with room to grow. 

You can read the full broker with program case study here. 

TayconRisk: Daily Manual Pain Points Down to Near Zero 

Taycon is a two-person MGA writing complex and hard-to-place commercial risks. Before automation, quotes were keyed by hand, rating lived in spreadsheets, documents were built one at a time and bordereaux reporting was a grind. 

Taycon’s first priority was automating documents, accounting and reporting, the work eating most of the team’s day. Since going live, Taycon has responded to brokers faster, grown revenue by broker and reduced its daily manual pain points to near zero. That leaves the team free to focus on underwriting the complex risks that are its specialty. 

In each case, the gain came from removing work, not adding headcount. For the full financial picture, see Beyond Headcount: The Real ROI of Automation for MGAs and Insurers. 

5 Question Workload Audit for Insurance Leaders 

You don’t need a consultant to find avoidable workload. Ask your team these five questions: 

  1. How many times is the same information typed? 
  2. How many screens does it take to issue one policy? 
  3. What share of renewals require a person’s touch? 
  4. How many hours does month-end reporting take? 
  5. How far behind are you? 

The answers will help show you where the avoidable work is and they’ll also give you a baseline so you can measure what changes. 

The Bottom Line 

The labour shortage isn’t going away soon and heavy workload has topped the Canadian Underwriter’s stressor list for two years running. One way to help is to stop asking skilled people to spend their days on work a system can do.  

Removing avoidable work won’t solve everything the survey describes. It gives your team back time and attention for parts of the job that need them: judgement, relationships and service.  

Talk to our team about where automation and AI would make the biggest difference in your operation. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

How can insurers reduce staff workload without hiring? 

Start by removing work that doesn’t need a person: duplicate data entry, manual document assembly, renewal rebuilds and report exports. A policy administration system that automates these tasks and integrates with accounting and other tools lets the same team handle more volume. My Mutual Insurance, for example, cleared a 3 to 8 month backlog without adding staff. 

What insurance tasks can be automated? 

Common examples include submission intake, referral decisions, dec page and document generation, accounting entries, payment schedules, renewals, sanctions checks and bordereaux reporting. The best candidates are repetitive, rules-based tasks that happen on every policy. 

Does automation replace underwriters? 

No. Automation handles the routine administrative work around underwriting, and sends underwriters the cases that need their judgement. The organizations in this article moved staff into service, sales and complex underwriting rather than reducing their teams. 

What is straight-through processing in insurance? 

Straight-through processing means a transaction, such as a quote, policy issue or renewal, completes without a person touching it. Rules decide whether it proceeds, and only exceptions are routed to staff for review. 

Why is duplicate data entry a problem in insurance operations? 

Every time the same information is typed into another system, it takes time and creates a chance for error. Those errors then take more time to find and fix. Entering data once and letting it flow to documents, accounting and reporting removes both problems.